Medicare gives home health agencies two separate star ratings. The quality of patient care rating shows how an agency’s patients did on measures like starting care on time and getting better at walking or bathing. The patient survey rating shows how patients said their care went.
Both use a 1-to-5 star scale and come from Medicare’s Care Compare website. They are a useful starting point, but they are not a grade on every nurse or every visit. Use them alongside your own phone calls and your parent’s doctor’s advice.
The quality of patient care star rating
This rating comes from information agencies already report to Medicare. CMS says it is based on OASIS assessments, which are the standard forms nurses and therapists fill out when a patient starts and ends care, and on Medicare claims data.
CMS’s star ratings page lists seven measures behind this rating:
- Timely initiation of care: how often the agency started care on time.
- Improvement in walking or moving around (ambulation).
- Improvement in getting in and out of bed (bed transferring).
- Improvement in bathing.
- Improvement in shortness of breath.
- Improvement in taking medicines by mouth correctly.
- Potentially preventable hospital stays during home health care.
In plain terms, this rating asks: did the agency show up on time, did patients tend to get stronger and more independent, and did they avoid trips back to the hospital that might have been prevented?
How the stars are set
The rating compares each agency with all other Medicare-certified agencies in the country. According to CMS’s frequently asked questions, the final rating runs from 1 to 5 in half-star steps. A score of 2.5 or 3 stars on a measure means the agency is performing about the same as the national middle. Higher means better than most; lower means worse than most.
So a rating in the middle of the scale points to average results, not failing ones. CMS updates the ratings every quarter, so an agency’s stars can move up or down over time.
The patient survey star rating
The second rating comes from the Home Health Care CAHPS survey, often shortened to HHCAHPS. CMS describes it as the first national, standard survey of home health patients about their experience. Medicare-certified agencies hire approved outside vendors to send the survey by mail, phone or both to current or recent patients.
The survey asks about things families care about, such as:
- Whether staff treated the patient gently, with courtesy and respect.
- How well staff communicated and kept the patient informed.
- Specific care topics like home safety, medicines and pain.
- An overall rating of the agency’s care on a 0 to 10 scale.
Medicare notes that a low survey rating does not mean you will get poor care. It reflects what past patients reported. CMS introduced a revised, shorter version of the survey in 2026, so the questions behind this rating are changing. Look at the individual survey results on an agency’s Care Compare page, not just the summary stars.
Why some agencies have no rating
You will see “Not available” or no stars for some agencies. That usually does not mean anything is wrong. It means the agency did not have enough data for Medicare to calculate a fair score.
- Quality of patient care rating: CMS says an agency must have been Medicare-certified for at least six months and must report enough data on at least five of the seven measures. Each measure needs at least 20 completed patient episodes over a 12-month period.
- Patient survey rating: CMS says an agency needs at least 40 completed surveys over four quarters to get survey stars. Agencies with fewer surveys may still have some survey results posted, just without stars.
New agencies and small agencies are the most likely to be missing a rating. A small agency might have a rating one quarter and not the next as its patient count changes. If an agency you like has no stars, ask how long it has been Medicare-certified and how many patients it serves in your area, then check its Florida license and inspection history.
How to use Care Compare
Care Compare is Medicare’s official tool for finding and comparing providers, including home health agencies.
- Go to Medicare.gov Care Compare and choose home health services.
- Enter your parent’s home ZIP code or city.
- Review the list of agencies that serve that area. Each one shows its star ratings when available.
- Open an agency’s page to see the individual measures, the services it offers and its patient survey results.
- Pick two or three agencies to compare, then call them.
Our agency search uses Medicare’s data for the Medicare-certified agencies serving Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach. Each profile shows the quality star rating, the patient survey stars when available, the services offered, the cities and counties served, and a link to the agency’s Care Compare page.
Tips for reading the ratings
- Look at the measures that matter to your parent. If your parent is recovering from a hip replacement, improvement in walking and getting in and out of bed may matter more than shortness of breath.
- Compare agencies that serve the same area. A high rating does not help if the agency cannot send staff to your parent’s address.
- Read both ratings together. An agency can score well on outcomes and lower on patient experience, or the other way around.
- Check the date. Ratings are updated quarterly and are based on past months of data, so they may not reflect recent changes in staff.
- Do not stop at the stars. Ask about start dates, language skills, after-hours support and hurricane plans. Our guide on choosing an agency walks through the questions.
Star ratings are only one piece of the picture. Your parent’s doctor, hospital case manager or therapist may also know which agencies work well for certain needs. Ask them too.